Logging Crossed Line into Oso Landslide Zone

By John Ryan

Seattle just wrapped up its wettest March on record. Geologists say heavy rain in the Cascade Mountains northeast of Seattle was key in triggering the landslide that killed at least people in the town of Oso last week. But they say clearcutting nearby could also have worsened the risk of the hillside collapsing.

Paul Kennard is looking out over a crumbling cliff face. It rises above a beach where Seattle meets Puget Sound.

Kennard: "We're standing on top of a landslide that's geologically similar to the one that occurred near Oso, Washington."

Kennard is a geomorphologist. That means he studies the way water and other forces shape the land, including the deep landslides that often hit the slopes and shorelines of Washington state.

Kennard: "It's almost universally accepted by scientists that water is a dominant control on these large landslides. Generally, the more you lubricate, once the water percolates down to the clay, that's when these things start to move more frequently and more quickly."

Rain is the fuel for landslides in wet western Washington. The tall trees of the Evergreen State help hold the ground together, not just with their roots, but also by soaking up rain before it goes deep underground. That's why the state essentially prohibits clearing of forests in places where groundwater can pool beneath a landslide zone.

Kennard: "The clearing just makes it much more vulnerable for when you have a wet winter like now."

Kennard works at Mt. Rainier National Park now. But in the 1980s he worked for the Tulalip Tribes north of Seattle. Even back then, tribes and state officials knew the Oso site had a long history of landslides large and small. 26 years ago, Kennard helped the tribes stop a clearcut on the same slope that gave way last week. The tribes saw it as a victory for the salmon they depend on in the Stillaguamish River at the base of the muddy slope.

Kennard: "We considered it a victory because the Department of Natural Resources, who has say over these things, this was the first time to our knowledge that they actually prohibited clearcutting of trees because there seemed to be a connection with landslides."

So, on the night of the latest slide, Kennard was surprised when he looked up the area on Google Earth. He saw an aerial photograph with a clearcut from 2005 right at the edge of the landslide zone.

Kennard: "I thought, whoa, that seems to be awfully close."

Aerial photos taken of the Oso slide last week show a wall of exposed earth hundreds of feet high, almost directly below that 2005 clearcut.

State officials say the cut they approved was safe: it was just outside the no-logging area intended to keep groundwater from building up. But those aerial photos also show that the seven-acre clearcut crossed the line. Here's Washington State Forester Aaron Everett.

Everett: "It appears, though we continue to investigate, that there's been an intrusion into the no-harvest area."

That intrusion apparently happened at the hands of the landowner, a small timber company called Grandy Lake Forest Associates. But the company has not responded to interview requests.

Everett: "We, as everyone else, have not been able to get a hold of the landowner. I don't know their status."

While his agency prohibits logging in the groundwater zones of landslide areas, Everett doesn't see logging playing a big role in this slide.

Everett: "The information we have is that the primary factors in this landslide were the erosion of the hillside below by the river, the nature of the soils themselves, being an area that's had landslides for going on over 10,000 years, and the amount of rain that happened."

That 2005 clearcut? The state allowed it right on the boundary of a no-logging zone that didn't reflect the latest scientific information. State-funded research from eight years before the clearcut showed the groundwater danger zone clearly overlapping with the area the state OK'd for clearcutting. Everett says the DNR is investigating what happened.

Everett: "The protections that the department puts in place to ensure that timber harvest do not contribute to landslide hazards are rigorous and are designed to protect public safety and natural resources. It's a difficult thing to talk about in the face of a tragedy like this."

Geologists say identifying where groundwater moves beneath a landslide zone is hard to do precisely.
Here's geomorphologist Paul Kennard: "Perhaps what is sort of the legal definition of the groundwater recharge area is actually a small part of the real groundwater recharge area. All that area has been cut and it takes decades to recover."

Kennard urges more cautious landuse anywhere near one of these deep-seated landslide zones.
But geologists also urge people not to jump to conclusions about the role of one small clearcut in 300-acre landslide. They say detailed study of this slide is needed before concluding how much of a role, if any, the recent clearcutting played.

Download
Currently Playing
Schedule Grid KPBX 91.1
The Bookshelf
6:30pm 7:00pm
Schedule Grid KSFC 91.9
All Things Considered
6:00pm 7:00pm
Click for Spokane, Washington Forecast
SPR Family of Underwriters: